It occurred to me just now, about the conundrum I’ve been having with reconciling certain known “canon” parameters vis-à-vis
CT, O, their relative positions both between them proper, Beheic languages generally, and history. I’ve been speaking of the “Tim Ar-O languages” for quite a while; of Beheic itself, not quite that long but also not exactly a new idea. I have been trying out sound change schemas in Brassica
1 to try to get something that felt right. Brassica worked well; nothing I could come up with seemed germane.
Instead of merely reconstructing the
TO branch of Beheic, what is the source of the words in question? What if it
was actually
PB after all, and the
TO node split from Core Beheic happened early on? This could also affect how tones were generated (if at all).
As it currently stands, what
originally was just Proto-Tim Ar-O is now Proto-Beheic; the Tim Ar and O branches split in the midst of, or just after, the tonogenesis (
i.e., for Proto-Tim Ar-O, the buck stops at the initial point of tonogenesis). Tim Ar didn't do anything fancier than high/nonhigh. O, on the other hand, kept innovating on the tone side of things but then somehow lost the tone feature entirely, which explains the large number of homophones, kind of like in some Chinese lects or that one dialect of Klingon that had the voiced stops merge into the nasals (or in the case of /ɖ/, reflect as [ɳ]). So, if that can be made to work plausibly, maybe that’s a longstanding issue solved.
Before the shared tonogenesis, there were a few other attributes that the
TO branch ended up inheriting, some things slightly ahead in the queue of the order of operations. Might as well start with the famous
2 one: the “Great Vocalic Dispersal”. This is just an overly fancy way of saying that the vowel space in the language radically shifted in certain specific ways. It’s generally considered that the [something about the coda consonants and their uneven distribution due to, I guess, euphony?]. One may wonder why not simply reconstruct the vowel as just inherently rounded? Comparative method suggests that actual consonants were in there. In the
TO branch, the (already heavily restricted) codas had all merged into
*-β *-j *-ʁ.
Thus we can simultaneously innovate in one of several ways whilst still largely respecting extant canon.
The aspirate/tenuis series’ distribution is a function of the reflex of glottalization: A vowel that typically was understood to be glottalized ended up having a low tone and increasing voice onset time until the point where it stopped being a fight anymore.
glottalized > low tone > aspirate (positive
VOT)
Proto-Beheic phonology
…would be something like this, then:
/*m *n̪ *n *nʲ *ŋ/
/*p *t̪ *t *tʲ *k *q *ʔ/
/*θ *s *ʃ *h/
/*β *ð *ɹ *ʁ/
/*a *ə *ɨ/, plus glottalization /*ˀ/
PB *(C)(R)V(ˀ)(D) >
PTO *(C(ʰ))(R)V(G)
where
R is any sonorant consonant and
D is any sonorant consonant or
*t̪ *t *tʲ.
Lenition comes with deglottalization?
Intervocalic lenition, blocked by vowel glottalization feature, subsequent lenition to different phone when glottalization converts to
VOT
Proto-Beheic to Proto-Tim Ar-O
First lenition: *-p *-t̪ *-t *-tʲ {*-k,*-q} *-ʔ > *-β *-ð *-ɹ *-j *-ʁ *-ʔ / V _ {V,#}
Glottalic phonic forcing: *Vˀ >
*V̀, thence >
*hV if no onset,
ʰV if
*C(R)-,
*R- >
*F- (original
*F unaffected)
The great vowel dispersal:
- *{a,ə} *ɨ > *a *ɨ / _ ʁ, ʁ _ (phonation maintained)
- *ʁ > *Ø / _ #
- In syllables having coda *-j-, the central vowels front to *ɛ *e *i; with coda *-β-, they round (and back) to *ɔ *o *u.
- Coda and intervocalic *β *j, once their effects have been transferred, disappear.
- Now the onsets. Palatal onsets produce the fronted outcomes; labial ones, the rounded (and backed) ones.
- *ə *ɨ > *a *i / {K,Q} (R) _ , _ (C) #
- *{ə,ɨ} > *e…kind of speaks for itself, really.
The first tonogenesis:
- *V0V0 > *V́0
- *V > *V́ / {[+asp],[+cont -son]} ([+son]) _
- [+asp] [+cont -son] > [-asp] [+son]
- *h > *Ø
And then it is
here that Tim Ar and O part ways.
To CT
Final stop loss: Nothing too fancy here—
*S > [/i]Ø / _#[/i].
First spirantization: *S >
F / _{j,i,u} except *ʔ.
Parasonorant high vowel deletion: [+syll +hi] >
Ø/ _ R, R _.
7-to-5 vowel merger: *ɛ *e *ɔ *o >
e i o u.
Second spirantization: This is a bit of a misnomer as nasals were affected too.
- [+syll +hi] > Ø / {C,V} V (C) (ʔ) _ #
- *N *S > S F / _ʔ
- *ɸ *θ *s *ɬ *ʃ *x *χ > u i i a i a a / ʔ _ #
- *ʔ > Ø
Vowel system conversion: Oh, boy, here we go.
- [+bk +ro] > [-bk +fr] / j _
- [+fr -ro] > [-fr +bk] / β _
- *{β,j} > Ø / C _ {a,á}
- *β > Ø / _ [+fr +ro]
- *j > Ø / _ [+bk -ro]
- *β *j > p tʲ / _ V
- *V0V0 > V́
- [+syll +bk +ro] > [-bk +fr] / _ E
- *E > Ø / [+syll +fr +ro] _
- [+syll +fr -ro] > [-fr +bk] / _ B
- B] > Ø / [+syll +bk -ro]
The Chain:
- *l > ʕ
- *θ *ð *t̪ *n̪ > ɬ l t n
- *s *ʃ > θ s
- *nʲ *tʲ > n s
- *C > Ø / # p _ V
*p-affectation: *ð *ɹ *l >
tθ ts tɬ with some conditioning involving
*p (and maybe
*k *q?)
Stop lenition:
- *p *q > h x
- *t *k > ɹ ʕ / [+vc] _ {[+vc],#}
Cleanup:
- *h > Ø / # S _
- [+syll +hi] > Ø / {V,C} F _ (not sure what I had in mind when I wrote that down but here it is)
Prenasal raising: *a *á >
*æ *ǽ / _ N
Voicing rule: [-syll -vc] > [+vc] / [+vc]
_ {[+vc]
,#} (
*h exempted from this)
Needle clusters:
- *nt > ndɹ
- *θ *s *ɬ > d̪ð dz dɬ / {n,ɹ,l} _
- *Ø > s / t _ k, k _ t
Prenasal low vowel raising: *a *á >
æ ǽ / _ N.
[/list]
To PO
Thorns and palatals: *θ *ð were lost before a consonant and became
h elsewhere;
*t̪ *n̪ merged with plain ol’
t n, and all the palatals lenited to
j.
Glottalic saps: *ʔB *ʔE >
w j when following a vowel; initial
*ʔV- sequences are lost thanks to the glottal stop spoiling the fun.
Glide fortition: *w *j *ʁ >
*p *t *k in three environments: word-initially before another glide, following a word-initial glottal stop, or when geminate (
i.e., like glides fortite the first).
*q who?: A merger of
*q into
k.
Terminal *-hV: *h + one of
*u *ú *i *í becomes either of
w j, as appropriate, word-finally.
Second tonogenesis:
- *V́ʔ *Vʔ > *V̂ *V̀
- *V (any tone) > *V̄ / [+syll] _
- *B *A *E > *w *ʁ *j / _ [+syll]
- *ww *ʁʁ *jj > *w *ʁ *j / #C_
Vowel height reduction: *ɔ in all tones becomes
*wa (retaining the tone), and
*i in all tones lowered to
*e when adjacent to
*j.
Loss of harmonic postglottal vocoids: This is just a fancy way of saying that when you have
*-ʔji *-ʔwu (in all tones), it goes poof. gone.
Reassignment of neutral tone: The tone system, much like Mandarin, has four tones plus a “neutral” tone (heretofore denoted by its lack of a diacritic
3); the neutral tone got reassigned. The neutral tone became circumflex except in three environments—
- When the vowel in the next syllable carried a high tone, the neutral tone became high as well;
- When word-finally or immediately before a word-final nasal and the vowel in the penult was not low-tone, the vowel was lost entirely; and
- When word-final or preceding a word-final *w *j (not *ʁ) though), the vowel instead took the mid tone.
Nasal jettison: *m became
*w when initial and
*p otherwise;
*ŋ became
*k in all positions.
Mid-front mergers: The
*ɛ vowel, in all its tones, raised to and merged with corresponding
*e. All tones of
*a became
*ʁ when standing after
*e.
Droppage of final -*ʔV: Final sequences of glottal stop plus any vowel drop.
Final-*is: *i in all tones becomes corresponding
*e word-finally before a glottal stop (which then deletes).
Tone abandon: Tone was lost; if the vowel was low, mid, or circumflex and preceded a glide (
i.e., one of
*w *j *ʁ), it left behind a glottal stop.
Postglottalic glide fortition: The sequences
*ʔw *ʔj *ʔʁ became
*p *t *k; when one of
*p *t *k + glide followed, the glottal stop instead became
*w *j *ʁ, as appropriate.
*o fortuna: Before
*e, the sequences
*jo *ju became
*j *w. Remaining
*jo became
*ja instead; the leftover
*o merged with
*u.
Lambda loss: *l became
*nt when intervocalic and
*n elsewhere.
*e-ncore: Initial
*eC- sequences metathesized, with the resulting
*-eV- sequence changing the latter element to its corresponding glide. Additionally, word-initially or after a word-initial consonant,
*-ee- sequences become
*-je-.
Loss of initial prelaryngeal vowels: *V0- >
*Ø / # _ h V0.
PO allophonic processes: The synchrony of Proto-O.
- *-p *-t *-k > *-f *-s *-x
- *p *t *k > *pf *ts *kx / _{j,i}
- *n > *m / _pf
- *n > *ŋ / _kx
- *t > *d / n_{R,V,#}
- *np *ng > *mb *ŋg / when not _{f,x}
- *aG- > *ʁa-
- *a > *ʁ / _e
- *ʁ > *k / _ʁ
So, uh…yeah, I think that works!
- Brassica is awesome. bradrn, thank you so much for this tool, and for sharing it with us.
- In-universe.
- Which makes writing about the vowel all at once tricky.