Suppletions for "to be"
Suppletions for "to be"
This is a thread for verbs and other words which have supplied suppletive forms of "to be" in various languages. To start with, in IE alone there are "to sit" and "to stand" in Italic, "to remain" in Germanic, and perhaps most oddly "to arise" in Old English. What others do you know of?
Self-referential signatures are for people too boring to come up with more interesting alternatives.
Re: Suppletions for "to be"
Isn't 'be' itself from PIE *bʰuH- 'to grow' with an intermediate sense of 'to become'?
Anyway, for a field day of content verbs grammaticalising into copulas, somebody could bring up Sino-Tibetan copulas.
Anyway, for a field day of content verbs grammaticalising into copulas, somebody could bring up Sino-Tibetan copulas.
/j/ <j>
Ɂaləɂahina asəkipaɂə ileku omkiroro salka.
Loɂ ɂerleku asəɂulŋusikraɂə seləɂahina əɂətlahɂun əiŋɂiɂŋa.
Hərlaɂ. Hərlaɂ. Hərlaɂ. Hərlaɂ. Hərlaɂ. Hərlaɂ. Hərlaɂ.
Ɂaləɂahina asəkipaɂə ileku omkiroro salka.
Loɂ ɂerleku asəɂulŋusikraɂə seləɂahina əɂətlahɂun əiŋɂiɂŋa.
Hərlaɂ. Hərlaɂ. Hərlaɂ. Hərlaɂ. Hərlaɂ. Hərlaɂ. Hərlaɂ.
-
- Site Admin
- Posts: 2944
- Joined: Sun Jul 08, 2018 5:46 am
- Location: Right here, probably
- Contact:
Re: Suppletions for "to be"
Mandarin 是 shì 'be' was a demonstrative pronoun 'this' in Old Chinese.
There's also OC 为 wéi 'make' > 'function as ' > 'be'.
There's also OC 为 wéi 'make' > 'function as ' > 'be'.
Re: Suppletions for "to be"
For Japanese, the polite copula です desu is generally considered a contraction of であります de arimasu, where the first element is a locative particle and the latter is a verb of existence. But other contractions have been proposed, such as で する de suru, with the light verb generally used to verbify nouns etc. The plain form だ da has some inflections supplied by the verb なる naru "reach".
-
- Posts: 128
- Joined: Mon Jul 09, 2018 6:08 am
Re: Suppletions for "to be"
Australian languages sometimes use "sit" and "stand" in a similar way to "be". Bardi is one example. There is one language (unfortunately can't remember the name!) where the correct verb, for inanimates, depends on the shape and position of the object - it could be any of "stand" (for example a spear in the ground), "sit" or "crouch".
Re: Suppletions for "to be"
Another is "Iba" in Spanish, for the imperfect, which has a converse in English "I've been to...".
Self-referential signatures are for people too boring to come up with more interesting alternatives.