H/æ/lloween or H/ɑː/lloween, again
H/æ/lloween or H/ɑː/lloween, again
Because it is that time of the year again, and to avoid engaging in necromancy, here is a new thread for the perennial topic of H/æ/lloween versus H/ɑː/lloween.
Yaaludinuya siima d'at yiseka wohadetafa gaare.
Ennadinut'a gaare d'ate eetatadi siiman.
T'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa.
Ennadinut'a gaare d'ate eetatadi siiman.
T'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa.
Re: H/æ/lloween or H/ɑː/lloween, again
/haləwɪjn/, of course.
Less flippantly, it is definitely TRAP here, and a back vowel sounds American to my (British) ears*. Although our TRAP is lower and backer than yours, so they sound quite similar. Or in short, what Raphael said
* I'm not sure what phoneme it would even be if it appeared over here. PALM/START(/BATH) is long, LOT is back, rounded and raised, and has no tradition of being used for ⟨a⟩, or to represent foreign low vowels, aside from it sounding very wrong to be here. CUT is probably accoustically closest, but that (again) sounds very wrong
Less flippantly, it is definitely TRAP here, and a back vowel sounds American to my (British) ears*. Although our TRAP is lower and backer than yours, so they sound quite similar. Or in short, what Raphael said
* I'm not sure what phoneme it would even be if it appeared over here. PALM/START(/BATH) is long, LOT is back, rounded and raised, and has no tradition of being used for ⟨a⟩, or to represent foreign low vowels, aside from it sounding very wrong to be here. CUT is probably accoustically closest, but that (again) sounds very wrong
LZ – Lēri Ziwi
PL – Proto Lēric
PRk – Proto Rākēwuic
XI – Xú Iạlan
VN – verbal noun
SUP – supine
DIRECT – verbal directional
My language stuff
PL – Proto Lēric
PRk – Proto Rākēwuic
XI – Xú Iạlan
VN – verbal noun
SUP – supine
DIRECT – verbal directional
My language stuff
- linguistcat
- Posts: 453
- Joined: Sun Jul 08, 2018 12:17 pm
- Location: Utah, USA
Re: H/æ/lloween or H/ɑː/lloween, again
Both are acceptable variations to me. If anything, the version with /ɑ:/ sounds less American, but not completely unheard where I'm living in Idaho.
A cat and a linguist.
Re: H/æ/lloween or H/ɑː/lloween, again
I've always pronounced it the latter. I feel like the dark /l/ draws the initial vowel back.
Mureta ikan topaasenni.
Koomát terratomít juneeratu!
Anti-TESCREAL Action | He/him
Koomát terratomít juneeratu!
Anti-TESCREAL Action | He/him
Re: H/æ/lloween or H/ɑː/lloween, again
Personally I have /ɑː/ phonemically but [aː] phonetically. I've heard my dad pronounce it with /æ/ phonemically and [ɛː] phonetically, but the open-mid front vowel just sounds off to my ears (even though I have it in aloe, tallow, fallow, callow, and sallow and it doesn't sound weird to me there).
Yaaludinuya siima d'at yiseka wohadetafa gaare.
Ennadinut'a gaare d'ate eetatadi siiman.
T'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa.
Ennadinut'a gaare d'ate eetatadi siiman.
T'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa.
-
- Site Admin
- Posts: 2940
- Joined: Sun Jul 08, 2018 5:46 am
- Location: Right here, probably
- Contact:
Re: H/æ/lloween or H/ɑː/lloween, again
/halowin/. Same vowel as in hollow, holler; definitely not the same as in hall, haul or hallow, Hal.
Re: H/æ/lloween or H/ɑː/lloween, again
/ɑ ~ a/, never /æ/ (i do hear the latter sometimes but it's definitely less common than the former around here)
- WeepingElf
- Posts: 1505
- Joined: Sun Jul 15, 2018 12:39 pm
- Location: Braunschweig, Germany
- Contact:
Re: H/æ/lloween or H/ɑː/lloween, again
Most people here in Germany say ['hælowi:n], but apparently, they are just wrong
... brought to you by the Weeping Elf
My conlang pages
My conlang pages
Re: H/æ/lloween or H/ɑː/lloween, again
I actually think that the /æ/ pronunciation is the traditional one, as Halloween is derived from hallow, which normally takes /æ/.WeepingElf wrote: ↑Thu Oct 31, 2024 5:28 pm Most people here in Germany say ['hælowi:n], but apparently, they are just wrong
Yaaludinuya siima d'at yiseka wohadetafa gaare.
Ennadinut'a gaare d'ate eetatadi siiman.
T'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa.
Ennadinut'a gaare d'ate eetatadi siiman.
T'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa.
Re: H/æ/lloween or H/ɑː/lloween, again
I pronounce "Halloween" like in "hallow". The other pronunciation may have originated by analogy with "hollow", although the word "Halloween" has no etymological relation to "hollow".
Re: H/æ/lloween or H/ɑː/lloween, again
Of course, being the phonological oddball I am, my actual pronunciation of Halloween in everyday speech is [ˈhaːwːĩ(ː)n].
Yaaludinuya siima d'at yiseka wohadetafa gaare.
Ennadinut'a gaare d'ate eetatadi siiman.
T'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa.
Ennadinut'a gaare d'ate eetatadi siiman.
T'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa.
-
- Posts: 286
- Joined: Wed Jul 08, 2020 9:15 am
Re: H/æ/lloween or H/ɑː/lloween, again
Well, most German people I know say ['hɛlovi:n], because they have trouble with [æ] and [w].WeepingElf wrote: ↑Thu Oct 31, 2024 5:28 pm Most people here in Germany say ['hælowi:n], but apparently, they are just wrong
Re: H/æ/lloween or H/ɑː/lloween, again
Ironically, that phonologically matches the British pronunciation, but is phonetically closer to American (or very old-fashioned Bristish) pronounciation of that vowelWeepingElf wrote: ↑Thu Oct 31, 2024 5:28 pm Most people here in Germany say ['hælowi:n], but apparently, they are just wrong
LZ – Lēri Ziwi
PL – Proto Lēric
PRk – Proto Rākēwuic
XI – Xú Iạlan
VN – verbal noun
SUP – supine
DIRECT – verbal directional
My language stuff
PL – Proto Lēric
PRk – Proto Rākēwuic
XI – Xú Iạlan
VN – verbal noun
SUP – supine
DIRECT – verbal directional
My language stuff
Re: H/æ/lloween or H/ɑː/lloween, again
In cot-caught merged varieties, it may also result from spelling influence. "Hall o ween"
Re: H/æ/lloween or H/ɑː/lloween, again
The dialect here isn't cot-caught merged. My suspicion is that the [w] in Halloween exhibits a retracting influence at a distance. (In the dialect here /oʊ/ [o̞] cannot occur before another vowel in the same word except if another consonant was elided in between -- normally [w] is inserted in between except in cases of elision.) This is amplified by pronunciations like my own where the /loʊ/ assimilates to the [w] to give [wː].
Yaaludinuya siima d'at yiseka wohadetafa gaare.
Ennadinut'a gaare d'ate eetatadi siiman.
T'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa.
Ennadinut'a gaare d'ate eetatadi siiman.
T'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa.
Re: H/æ/lloween or H/ɑː/lloween, again
OK, on second thoughts, I'm not at all sure what precise vowel I use in the first syllable; all I know for sure is that it's not /a:/. Or any long vowel.
Re: H/æ/lloween or H/ɑː/lloween, again
The vowel length I specified is just part of conventional English phonemic notation. Many English varieties, especially NAE varieties but also ones such as Scottish Standard English, have lost phonemic vowel length, leaving only vowel length allophony. (Some varieties such as my own could be argued to have reintroduced phonemic vowel length, but to me that would only be the case for naive, shallow analyses; there is good reason to argue that vowel length is still allophonic given deep analyses of at least my own dialect..)
Yaaludinuya siima d'at yiseka wohadetafa gaare.
Ennadinut'a gaare d'ate eetatadi siiman.
T'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa.
Ennadinut'a gaare d'ate eetatadi siiman.
T'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa.
Re: H/æ/lloween or H/ɑː/lloween, again
Interesting. I would have thought the main difference between the BATH vowel and the BUT vowel was length.Travis B. wrote: ↑Fri Nov 01, 2024 11:14 am
The vowel length I specified is just part of conventional English phonemic notation. Many English dialects, especially NAE dialects but also ones such as Scottish Standard English, have lost phonemic vowel length, leaving only vowel length allophony. (Some varieties such as my own could be argued to have reintroduced phonemic vowel length, but to me that would only be the case for naive, shallow analyses; there is good reason to argue that vowel length is still allophonic given deep analyses of at least my own dialect..)
Re: H/æ/lloween or H/ɑː/lloween, again
Depends on the variety. In many varieties STRUT is a (short, when phonemic) unrounded near-open central vowel and PALM is a (long, when phonemic) unrounded (or in CanE, rounded) open back vowel, as is BATH when it is not the same as TRAP. In my own variety, like other Inland North varieties, STRUT is an unrounded open-mid back vowel, PALM is an unrounded open central or front vowel, and BATH is the same as TRAP (i.e. an unrounded open-mid vowel prone to diphthongization, particularly before nasals). The system that you describe, where STRUT differs from BATH and PALM primarily by vowel length is typical of AusE, where both are unrounded open or near-open central vowels which differ primarily in length.Raphael wrote: ↑Fri Nov 01, 2024 11:19 amInteresting. I would have thought the main difference between the BATH vowel and the BUT vowel was length.Travis B. wrote: ↑Fri Nov 01, 2024 11:14 am
The vowel length I specified is just part of conventional English phonemic notation. Many English dialects, especially NAE dialects but also ones such as Scottish Standard English, have lost phonemic vowel length, leaving only vowel length allophony. (Some varieties such as my own could be argued to have reintroduced phonemic vowel length, but to me that would only be the case for naive, shallow analyses; there is good reason to argue that vowel length is still allophonic given deep analyses of at least my own dialect..)
Yaaludinuya siima d'at yiseka wohadetafa gaare.
Ennadinut'a gaare d'ate eetatadi siiman.
T'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa.
Ennadinut'a gaare d'ate eetatadi siiman.
T'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa t'awraa.